Loading…

C.H. Robinson calls lawsuit ‘meritless’

In response to a lawsuit filed against C.H. Robinson claiming that the firm engaged in illegal business activities, the typically tight-lipped company issued a relatively lengthy denial stating that the complaint is “meritless” and filled with “blatant mischaracterizations and fabrications.”  

The CHR response also theorized that the suit was filed so that some growers “could avoid paying their debts” to the firm.

According to press reports, the lawsuit was filedby a group of farmers in mid-January in federal court in Minnesota asking for a total of $1.1 billion for allegedly overcharging shipping costs while pocketing the additional profits and underpaying farmers for various types of produce from both North America and South America.

The lawsuit alleges “freight topping,” stating that CHR and its Robinson Fresh division regularly overcharged freight costs, took profits and failed to disclose those profits, which, the suit claims, violates provisions in the federal Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act.

The lawsuit reportedly claims that these freight profits exceeded $1,000 per load of produce.

The lawsuit has not been given class action status yet, but the plaintiffs have requested it, according to published reports. If granted, many other growers could join the suit.

Contacted for comment, CHR released a statement, noting its typical reluctance to do so. It follows in its entirety. 

“C.H. Robinson usually doesn’t comment on pending litigation; however, we feel it is important to share our views on this. First, we are proud of our longstanding relationships with growers throughout the world. The complaint was designed to capture media attention, and itcontains an enormous amount of self-serving falsehoods as well as blatant mischaracterizations and fabrications about our company, teams and the actual agreements signed by the growers themselves.It is important to note that the lawsuit has not been certified as a class action at this time, and C.H. Robinson will oppose any attempt to certify it as such.We deny any and all allegations of wrongdoing and look forward to vigorously defending our actions, as well as filing legitimate counterclaims against the growers.  

“C.H. Robinson loaned several of the growers listed in the complaint money to finance their businesses. Now that the money is due to be repaid, these growers are using this complaint to avoid paying their debts. C.H. Robinson will assert its right to collect the significant amounts it is owed by the growers.  

“C.H. Robinson always complies with federal statutes and state regulations; the company did not violate any express or implied duties to the growers. In fact, the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act (PACA) division conducted an onsite, seven-day investigation into the allegations contained in the complaint; this is standard protocol in instances like this. C.H. Robinson cooperated and supported their thorough investigation and at no time during or after the investigation, did the USDA PACA division advise of any irregularities or take any disciplinary actions against C.H. Robinson as a result of their investigation.”

The statement also included a direct quote from Michael Castagnetto, president of Robinson Fresh, who said,“We are proud of the work we do with our teams, growers, and customers throughout the world, and we look forward to putting this entirely meritless complaint behind us.”

United Fresh LIVE! Community – Collaboration – Innovation
United Fresh LIVE! is a response to an unprecedented challenge to our industry and our world. While citizens around the globe are social distancing and avoiding physical connections, our industry must continue to find creative ways to continue doing business, and trade shows are a large part of that strategy for the fresh Read More ...
Kroger expands plans for high-tech fulfillment centers
The Kroger Family of Cos. and Ocado announced the continued expansion of their partnership with plans to construct three new customer fulfillment centers in the Great Lakes, Pacific Northwest and West regions.   "Kroger is incredibly excited to construct three additional industry-leading Customer Fulfillment Centers across Read More ...
Onions 52 welcomes Food Lion's Clay Jones to sales team
Onions 52 Inc. has welcomed Clay Jones to its sales and business development team. Jones is based in San Antonio, TX, and will be focusing on new account development and expanding business with current customers. “We could not be happier to have Clay join our team,” said Shawn Hartley, vice president of sales. “With Clay’s Read More ...
Simple labeling changes can escalate sales
Simple changes on a produce packaging label can drastically influence consumer purchases of that product. Tony Cook, chief executive officer of Great Lakes Label LLC, said his customers have seen this immediately build retail sales by as much as 30 percent. Cook, who in 1994 started the company in Comstock, MI, credits the Read More ...
Tops' new safety and risk leader
Tops Friendly Markets, a leading full-service grocery retailer in New York, northern Pennsylvania and Vermont, promoted Natalie Fisher to manager of safety and risk for the company. Fisher began her career with Tops in the stores in 2001 and was promoted to various roles until her appointment as safety specialist for the Read More ...
Giltner sees silver lining amid coronavirus pandemic
The current coronavirus pandemic has presented challenges that few could have imagined. In the face of those challenges, Giltner Inc. has found a way to stay the course and continue to provide the high level of service its clients have come to expect. “We’ve had tough conversations with some of our customers, but they Read More ...

Market Watch

the source pro-act

Western growing regions getting hit by rain, cooler temps

floral pulse