A federal judge ruled May 18 that government agencies must take into
account the human costs -- not just the effect on wildlife -- when restricting
water allocations to farmers and other water users. The judge also stated that
decisions to cut farm water deliveries in Central California, with the expressed
intent of protecting endangered fish species, were based on flawed science.
The ruling in Fresno, CA, by U.S. District Judge Oliver Wanger, which is
expected to loosen restriction on pumping water from the Sacramento River
Delta into canal systems delivering water to agricultural and urban water
users south of the delta, is seen as a major victory for farmers who have been
forced to idle hundreds of thousands of acres of once-productive farmland in
California's San Joaquin Valley over the last two years due to cuts in water
The ruling came just one day after another major piece of good news for
California's beleaguered farmers was released by the University of Maryland.
A study by Patricia Gilbert, a researcher at the university's Center for
Environmental Science, confirmed - as farm groups in Central California have
been contending - that the dumping of inadequately treated sewage into the
delta by the city of Sacramento and other delta communities, and not the
pumping of water out of the delta, has been the major cause of declines in
populations of the endangered California Delta Smelt.
The University of Maryland study followed on the heels of a study completed
in February by Inge Werner, a toxicologist at the University of California-
Davis, which also indicated that Delta Smelts have been harmed more by
wastewater than by pumping.
Judge Wanger stated in his 134-page ruling that federal agencies are
obligated to assess the effects of their actions on "the quality of the human
In the specific case being considered, Westlands Water District and other
plaintiffs asked for a temporary restraining order against implementation of a
2009 National Marine Fisheries Service biological opinion favoring another
category of endangered fish species in the delta -- salmon -- over humans
in deciding distribution of water flowing into the delta.
In his ruling, Judge Wanger stated that "the evidence overwhelmingly
establishes significant detrimental effects visited on the quality of the human
environment" by implementation of the operating restrictions required by the
"The exact restrictions imposed, which are inflicting material harm to humans
and the human environment, are not supported by the record," he stated.
"Judicial deference is not owed to such arbitrary, capricious and scientifically
unreasonable agency actions."
The judge granted the requested injunction and scheduled a hearing for May
19 to address the specifics of the injunctive relief and specify how much
additional pumping from the delta must be permitted.
"This is a powerful, excellent ruling," said Brandon M. Middleton, an attorney
with the Pacific Legal Foundation, which represents some of the farmers that
have been adversely affected by federal water cutbacks. "The judge is telling
the feds that they can't ignore the harsh human and environmental impacts of
cutting off water to farms, workers, businesses and communities. The judge
is also saying the feds can't get away with using slippery science to justify
environmental restrictions that rob communities of their lifeblood: water."
Judge Wanger's ruling is "very positive," Joel Nelsen, president of California
Citrus Mutual in Exeter, CA, told The Produce News May 18. "Based on the
science that has now come out relative to the other stressors" on the delta,
the ruling now requires "the federal government to take a much broader and
comprehensive look at how to solve the problem without adversely affecting"
farmers and other water users in the San Joaquin valley.
What NMFS did in issuing its biological opinion "was abuse the scientific
process" by predetermining the desired outcome "and then trying to develop
a solution path to achieve it without taking into consideration all these other
dynamics," he said. "It was a corrupted scientific process."